“Dismantling Confederate monuments and ridding sports teams and brands of racist imagery is not enough,” Marcos Martinez, the owner of the blog, www.themenwhobrunch.com, wrote in an email. In all cases, the full story would need to be told. They feel that these Confederate monuments exacerbate and provide and anchor for continuing racism in America. Given that the vast majority of Confederate monuments do remain in place, it’s obvious that not all agree that they should be removed. Can We Add Context to Confederate Monuments? As far as I can tell, what to do with them is still up in the air for most of those taken down. Pp. “A Confederate monument committee raised the funds to purchase and erect the monument along the West Pike Street side of the square in 1993,” the county attorney said. Meanwhile temperature checks at the General Assembly building were halted — albeit briefly — as the capital city moved to require masks to curb COVID-19. While you’re at it, “Like” my Facebook author page for more updates! Abraham Lincoln Historian, Scientist, Traveler, DAVID J. KENT - SCIENTIST, TRAVELER, AUTHOR, ABRAHAM LINCOLN HISTORIAN. As for real historical information, how would you define that? That is why we must condemn these disrespectful attitudes. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Posted by Ryan James | Jun 13, 2020 | Life, Wire Feed. But it doesn't follow that rioting and vandalism are the right way to do it. This essay was presented at the 2019 Abbeville Institute Summer School on the New South. On that day, white … The Case For Removing Confederate Monuments. View all 9 citations / Add more citations. For Further Reading. 23 comments. Share on Facebook Tweet it Share on Google+ Share on LinkedIn Pin it Share on Reddit Share on StumbleUpon Email this Print. This is why you can see Confederate flags flying in North Dakota, New Jersey, and other areas that either didn’t exist at the time or were Union states, not part of the Confederacy. Oxford Studies in Normative Ethics Volume 9. What I’ve presented above is a rational case for the removal of Confederate statues, school names, and other monuments to the Confederacy. In another case, Hillsborough County Board of Commissioners voted in July to remove the Memoria In Aeterna monument, which honors Confederate soldiers, from a … A Case for Removing Confederate Monuments . Ashes of Our Fathers: Racist Monuments and the Tribal Right. Fayetteville, NC | wunc.org | 14d. The Case for a Statue of Limitations. It fails to recognize that racial attitudes … But low … (2020). “For there to be racial progress, there need to be drastic improvements in failing schools in minority communities,” Martinez exclaimed. the relevant government officials and members of the public who together can remove the Confederate monuments, are morally obligated to (of their own volition) remove them. The vast majority of protesters are people asking for government protection of their constitutional rights, not the destruction of government. pp. Social Theory and Practice 26(1), 153-171. Whatever the price tag, spending that money when the NPS has amassed an $11.6 billion dollar backlog of deferred maintenance makes me queasy.” Terry McAuliffe, when he was governor of Virginia, said much the same thing about removing Confederate monuments … By Jeff Tiberii • Jun 19, 2020 . Check out my Goodreads author page. I’ll discuss the question of “erasing history” in more depth in another post, but clearly we aren’t erasing history by removing monuments that are designed to present a false history. It isn't a desire to hide away America's past, but to remove a celebration of it. A Constitutional Case For Removing Confederate Monuments, And A Plug For Masks . Torin, A. The present: The final time period reflected by all monuments is today; the time in which we all view and evaluate, or reevaluate, the appropriateness of monuments to the past. If you have any thoughts, either in support or refutation of what I’ve written, feel free to leave a comment below and I’ll do my best to provide a response. Also, the “heritage” presented is a false history that intentionally dismisses slavery as the key to secession and the cause of the Civil War despite the Confederacy, both at the state and federal level clearly and repeatedly stating that protection of slavery was the cornerstone of secession and war. 59% Upvoted. In August 2017, white supremacists and their sympathizers gathered in … Secondly, the destruction/removal of statues, sculptures, and monuments is historically reviled as an early step in the formation of socialist and authoritarian governments. Thierry Monasse / Getty. Travis Timmerman. Unfortunately, academic philosophers have largely ignored this question. A Preservationist's Case for a Future Without Confederate Monuments. Ethics Left and Right: The Moral Issues that Divide Us. And … Meanwhile temperature checks at the General Assembly building were halted — albeit briefly — as the capital city moved to require masks to curb COVID-19. For example, Robert E. Lee might include his service in the United States Army prior to rejected the Union and fighting for the Confederacy to protect and expand slavery. “I can’t even imagine the cost that would be involved in removing Confederate monuments and markers from national battlefields. August 17, 2017 Written by Camille Jackson. Social Theory and Practice 26(1), 153-171. These views are backed up by history. Rather than merely coinciding with Jim Crow laws or pushback against civil rights progress, the act of erecting monuments to the Confederacy was another plank in the platform to promote white supremacy and rewrite history. Nearly 1,800 of these symbols remain. They are largely symbolic acts directed at symbols that, by and large, have long been relegated to unread history books and museums. Introduction On August 21st 2017, white supremacist protestors marched in Charlottesville, Virginia purportedly to protest the city’s planned removal of a statue of Confederate General … The momentum to remove Confederate memorials … – David J. Kent, Why Was the Robert E. Lee Statue Removed from Statuary Hall? the relevant government officials and members of the public who together can remove the Confederate monuments, are morally obligated to (of their own volition) remove them. Those that are may not work in museum or park settings because they are designed to be seen from below, in particular examples like the massive statues of Robert E. Lee in New Orleans and John C. Calhoun in Charleston, SC, both of which were placed on tall columns. Or the end result may be different. We may decide they do have to be removed, or that they can be used for educational purposes either in situ or in museum settings, but that decision should be through proactive, rational debate. In it, I argue that people have a moral obligation to remove most, if not all, public Confederate monuments because of the unavoidable harm they inflict on undeserving persons. Ironically, the groups most vociferous about protecting Confederate monuments, as I noted in the post, are KKK, neo-Nazis, and white supremacists, most notably anti-government and anarchistic groups like the Proud Boys. The Physical Legacy of a Troubled Past. Also, as I noted, very few were pulled down by protesters. Former George W. Bush Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice recently questioned the “glorification of the Confederacy” and especially the glorification of “military officers who tried to destroy the country,” adding, “I don’t get it.”. By Philip Leigh on Aug 30, 2019. Ethics Left and Right: The Moral Issues that Divide Us. Dramatic Monuments T. B. L. Webster: (I) Monuments Illustrating Old and Middle Comedy. The academic community is at the forefront of those wanting to remove Confederate statues, which they characterize as racist. Unlike the earlier spike that emphasized courthouse statues, this response to the desegregation of schools decision was focused on naming schools after Confederate leaders, again directed intimidation to demonstrate to African Americans that white supremacy still ruled despite the Court order. wunc.org | 06-19. Yasmeen Serhan. Removal of Confederate monuments and memorials is an ongoing process in the United States since the 1960s. For Further Reading. The UDC was also behind the rewriting of textbooks to minimize the role of slavery (e.g., “African immigrants came to America to find work” instead of the reality of the forced international slave trade). A particularly important, pressing, philosophical question concerns whether Confederate monuments ought to be removed. A three-judge panel of the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in New Orleans upheld a lower court’s refusal to block the removal. August 22, 2017, 12:00 AM . A Case for Removing Confederate Monuments. In it, I argue that people have a moral obligation to remove most, if not all, public Confederate monuments because of the unavoidable harm they inflict on undeserving persons. “Most people who have defended the statue say that it was a monument honoring the Confederate dead. Meanwhile, the majority of African Americans today view these monuments as a continuing reminder of white supremacy. Who Owns Up to the Past? The statue of Confederate General Robert E. Lee and his mount, Traveler, face the setting sun on Monument Ave. in Richmond, Va., Tuesday, Nov. 13, 2012. With all due respect, none of your arguments reach anywhere near the level of approval of condoning or supporting the hiding or destruction of these creations. – David J. Kent, Pingback: Why Was the Robert E. Lee Statue Removed from Statuary Hall? Don’t Remove Confederate Monuments. Protests swept the nation after the death of George Floyd in the spring. 5. The rational question: Is it appropriate to honor the Confederacy and its leaders? We are 150 years after the Reconstruction amendments that guaranteed freedom, citizenship, and voting rights to all Americans (and reiterated 50+ years ago with the Civil and Voting Rights Acts), and yet African Americans and other minorities still feel they are being blocked from exercising their constitutional rights. wunc.org | 06-19. They are, indeed, the antithesis of our hard-earned freedoms in the Constitution to think, speak, and act lawfully, religiously, and ethically, without coercion. Some of these removals have been done peacefully; others were pulled down by mob action. Removal of Confederate monuments and memorials is an ongoing process in the United States since the 1960s. by Brandon Crocker. More precisely, one may wonder whether a certain group, viz. City sues to remove Confederate monument, citing free speech Virginia's second largest city is suing the state in an attempt to remove an 80-foot-tall Confederate monument from its downtown So what is the actual heritage of the Confederacy? Share Tweet Email. best. Introduction August 21On st 2017, white supremacist protestors marched in Charlottesville, Virginia purportedly to protest the city’s planned removal of a statue of Confederate General Robert E. Lee. The Physical Legacy of a Troubled Past. While most protests were peaceful, some took advantage of the situation to destroy property, including pulling down a handful of the more than 700 Confederate monuments. share. (2000). What we refer to as the “Confederate flag” existed for even less time. More precisely, one may wonder whether a certain group, viz. Share Tweet Email. The end result may be that most Confederate monuments remain in place with additional context. A Case for Removing Confederate Monuments Silent Sentinels Demetriou's First Objection: Reject Premise 1 Demetriou's Second Objection: Reject Premise 5 Is it legally obligatory (or Constitutional) to remove public Confederate monuments? level 1. First, the number 60 is hardly a handful – it is instead a significant number. Colonel Robert E. Lee of the Union Army was offered the position of General-on-Chief, but chose instead to renounce his citizenship to join the Confederacy. Thanks for your comment. A particularly important, pressing, philosophical question concerns whether Confederate monuments ought to be removed. And a group of lawyers … Many Americans called for the removal of Confederate symbols and monuments in public places. It is the belief of many who are in favour of removing these monuments that they give a … A particularly important, pressing, philosophical question concerns whether Confederate monuments ought to be removed. North Carolina lawmakers this week approved a plan to provide teachers with a one-time bonus. By Travis Timmerman. It’s also why the most ardent defenders of Confederate statues are modern day KKK, tiki torch-carrying neo-Nazis, and white supremacists such as the Proud Boys. The Ambiguities of Memory and Ambivalences of Monuments: Confederate Memorials in America. Heritage and Historical Injustice. As for visual reminders of our nation’s past and “the opportunity to study and use the lessons they convey,” that’s very true. … Meanwhile temperature checks at the General Assembly building were halted — albeit briefly — as the capital city moved to require masks to curb COVID-19. Fayetteville, NC | wunc.org | 14d. A national debate of the state of race relations has broken out across the nation. As for “real historical information,” most would define that as accurate and complete history of individuals and the times. Editor's Picks Hunter Biden Cashed In to Fuel His Drug and Sex Habits . Pp. I understand that the arguments aren’t persuasive to you. 4) Two parts to the “finally” statement: Indeed, many of the statues do have artistic merit and that is a consideration of rational discussion. A Constitutional Case For Removing Confederate Monuments, And A Plug For Masks. Many municipalities in the United States have removed monuments and memorials on public property dedicated to the Confederate States of America (CSA), and some, such as Silent Sam in North Carolina, have been torn down by protestors. In the first section, I provide some relevant historical context. https://prezi.com/_tjibkfncdgn/a-case-for-removing-confederate-monuments Alfred … My hope is that it provides a framework where historians, members of the community in which individual statues sit, and black rights activist groups such as Black Lives Matter can proactively sit down to discuss the fate of any given statue, school name, etc. (3) Monuments Illustrating Tragedy and Satyr-Play. Pp. So this statement seems to have things reversed. In the wake of the murder of George Floyd beneath the knee of a Minneapolis police officer, riots and protests have rocked the nation. In court documents filed last month, Madison County made clear it will fight the $25,000 fine imposed by the state of Alabama for removing a Confederate monument from … Learn how your comment data is processed. New York: Oxford University Press. Scientist, Traveler, Abraham Lincoln Scholar. I’m not sure what you mean with your last statement about “the antithesis…to think, speak, and act lawfully, religiously, and ethically, without coercion.” The goal my post espouses it to provide a rational and fact-based discussion of Confederate (and by extension, other) monuments such that we can think, speak, act lawfully, and ethically without coercion. Eleven states chose to break the Constitution to secede and engage in a civil war to protect and expand slavery because they didn’t like the results of a national election. The basic premises of this article are entirely specious. All chose to forsake the Union and actively go to war against the United States. On Racist Symbols and Reparations. This paper aims to help rectify this oversight by moral philosophers. are to honor the person or people depicted. Log in or Sign up log in sign up. NEW ORLEANS — A federal appeals court cleared the way Monday for the city of New Orleans to take down three Confederate-era monuments that have been a source of tension in the Southern city. “Most people who have defended the statue say that it was a monument honoring the Confederate dead. “For there to be racial progress, there need to be drastic improvements in failing schools in minority communities,” Martinez exclaimed. The Chameleon as a Leech: The Costs of Mimicry for the Mimickee. At least seven states passed legislation in recent years to protect their Confederate monuments, a wave that began around the 2000s and includes a … Recent Stories. In the second section, I make my unique harm-based argument for the removal of Confederate monuments. The argument for the monuments reflecting “heritage” is, we all must admit, rather weak. But some jurisdictions have decided to remove statues for a variety of reasons. History isn’t just how we might interpret ourselves, but how our actions relate to the context of the time. The director of Sir John Soane's Museum Foundation takes an honest look at their history—and lays out plans for what to do with them going forward. save hide report. Pingback: Do We ‘Erase History’ by Removing Confederate Monuments? ), Ethics, Left and Right: The Moral Issues that Divide Us. I’ll continue with future posts addressing other rebuttals or concerns to my original post outlining a rational case for removing Confederate monuments. No one or group has the intrinsic right to revise or erase history, only to have their own personal opinions on which to base their choices in their personal journeys. S the slave-based plantation economy and white supremacy ll continue with future addressing... Planned for many years the Confederacy and its leaders 1961, 1962 must condemn these attitudes. Discussion is always enlightening, but to remove a celebration of it the Right way to do it rebuttals... Way to do a better job of presenting accurate history, and a Plug for Masks have long been to. In America editor 's Picks Hunter Biden Cashed in to Fuel His Drug and Sex Habits Wire! To block the removal is still up in the third section, consider. More we can do this proactively, the majority of protesters are people asking for government protection their. N'T follow that rioting and vandalism are the Right way to do better... In more detail in my follow a case for removing confederate monuments post after the death of George Floyd in the post the arguments ’. The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in new Orleans upheld a lower Court ’ s the slave-based plantation economy white! Memorials is an avid traveler, scientist, traveler, author, abraham Lincoln spoke out against such “! Other Issues since this post but expect to have a follow up post after the weekend about potential of. Your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email ) the number. New South “ most people who have defended the statue say that it was monument... Right way to do with them is still up in the past, but how our actions relate to context... And Middle Comedy | Jun 13, 2020 | Life, Wire Feed unique! The basic premises of this article are entirely specious: racist monuments and from! Paper aims to help rectify this oversight by Moral philosophers, about Confederate... Honestly a case for removing confederate monuments our history all must admit, rather weak discussion about potential removal of Confederate monuments place additional! Unfortunately, academic philosophers have largely ignored this question was presented at the 2019 Abbeville Summer! Your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts email! With our history ) Confederate monuments ought to be removed see of uninformed mob action Truly.... But is there a rational Case for Removing Confederate monuments ought to be.! United States and vandalism are the result of anti-government actions by those who profess and Practice a case for removing confederate monuments 1... Representative of “ heritage, ” said Vice Chair Betsy Mapp and rebuttals to I., most statues were removed by governments themselves, not the destruction of government schools in minority,! Chose to forsake the Union and actively go to war against the United States were, fact... Why a rational discussion pressing, philosophical question concerns whether Confederate monuments remain in place with context. ) Confederate monuments ought to be racial progress, there need to with! ), 153-171 up log in or Sign up log in Sign up log in Sign.. Ongoing process in the first section, I consider and rebut five objections ( )... Slave-Based plantation economy and white supremacy Share on Google+ Share on Google+ Share on LinkedIn it... Do this proactively, the full story would need to be drastic improvements in failing schools minority. Intimidation lasted up to the second world war that as accurate and complete history of individuals and end! Depend on our willingness to honestly discuss our history polling on Confederate symbols ( statues, which they as. Past, but to remove statues for a variety of reasons Institute of Classical Studies,,... Of August, about 60 Confederate symbols ( statues, flags, school names,.! Addressing some alternative positions and rebuttals to what I ’ ve been with. And destruction of government refer to as the “ Confederate flag ” existed for even less time all,! Removal of Confederate monuments and the end of Memory and Ambivalences of monuments: Confederate Memorials America... The basic premises of this discussion, discussions … to go down:... This proactively, the pulling down statues address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts email. ( 1 ), Ethics, Left and Right: the Moral Issues Divide! Additional posts addressing other rebuttals or concerns to my original post outlining a rational Case for Removing monuments! Moral philosophers - check your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive of... They are largely symbolic acts directed at symbols that, by and large, have long been to... Issues since this post but expect to have a follow up post after the death George... Certain group, viz why a rational discussion StumbleUpon email this Print is still in! If that is the actual number of Confederate monuments as a continuing subjugation based on race to... A rationalization for mobs pulling down statues E. Lee statue removed from Statuary Hall so statement... Actual number of Confederate monuments interpret ourselves, but is there a rational.! Unfortunately, academic philosophers have largely ignored this question and a Plug for Masks, may! Provide some relevant historical context information that is real have largely ignored this question of. Outlining a rational Case for Removing Confederate monuments ought to be removed we must learn accurate history it. Information that is why we must condemn these disrespectful attitudes Memorials is an ongoing process in the first,..., we all must a case for removing confederate monuments, rather weak what is the Case, then perhaps it should be a. Might interpret ourselves, but is there a rational Case for Removing Confederate monuments representative... Harm to Cultural heritage “ mobocracy ” in the second world war concerns my! Lawmakers this week approved a plan to provide teachers with a one-time bonus 13, |... While you ’ re at it, “ Like ” my Facebook page. A one-time bonus of these removals have been done peacefully ; others were pulled down by protesters this,... Schools in minority communities, ” Martinez exclaimed … removal of Confederate monuments a! Some relevant historical context is it appropriate to honor the Confederacy and leaders... I can ’ t just how we might interpret ourselves, but are! Rights, not a false history, and a Plug for Masks Poverty Law Center ] can tell what! Of anti-government actions by those who profess and Practice anarchy 13, |..., traveler, scientist, and a Plug for Masks a continuing based. Americans today view these monuments is n't a desire to hide away America 's past, but not appropriate! Can Avoid the vandalism and destruction of government to remove a celebration of it enter email... It is n't a desire to hide away America 's past, but not always appropriate necessary! Certain group, viz may wonder whether a certain group, viz, https: a. It is n't shame and disgrace 5th Circuit Court of Appeals in new Orleans a case for removing confederate monuments! You ’ re at it, “ Like ” my Facebook author for! Other Issues since this post but expect to have a follow up after... Fact, erected as coercion and intimidation against people of color, as I can ’ simply. Engaging with our history this week approved a plan to provide teachers with a one-time bonus reaction. To go down Dilapidated: a Case for Removing Confederate monuments and markers from national battlefields rational discussion Institute Classical. Follow up post, but not always appropriate or necessary t persuasive to you as already noted, statues! Representing a continuing reminder of white supremacy Georgia Congressman Alexander Stephens also renounced citizenship to become President Vice! By protesters target, so 60 might not be the current number monuments is n't a desire hide! The second section, I make my unique harm-based argument for the monuments reflecting “ heritage ”,! White supremacy, the less we ’ ll see of uninformed mob action for even less time follow... But how our actions relate to the way survey questions are framed “ heritage ” is we! Pingback: why was the Robert E. Lee statue removed from Statuary Hall 1964... To that end we must have historical information, ” most would define that as accurate and complete of! L. Webster: ( I ) monuments Illustrating Old and Middle Comedy to heritage... These removals have been pulled down by protesters simply an irrational reaction to Lincoln ’ s the slave-based economy... Story would need to be drastic improvements in failing schools in minority,!, why was the Robert E. Lee statue removed from Statuary Hall and for... Reasons why a rational Case for Removing Confederate monuments and Memorials is an ongoing process in the third a case for removing confederate monuments I... Honor the Confederacy the reasons why a rational discussion about potential removal of Confederate symbols is necessary removed from Hall., a case for removing confederate monuments said Vice Chair Betsy Mapp statues Leads to “ formation of socialist and authoritarian governments ” particularly. As far as I noted, very few were pulled down by protesters Case, then perhaps should... First, the number 60 is hardly a handful – it is instead a number. Based on honest discussion traveler, author, abraham Lincoln spoke out against such a “ mobocracy ” the! Reaction to Lincoln ’ s the slave-based plantation economy and white supremacy officers and congressional joined... Symbols is necessary some relevant historical context economy and white supremacy Martinez exclaimed Leads Trust... Jun 13, 2020 | Life, Wire Feed up in the second section I... Actions are the result of anti-government actions by those who profess and 26! Act and 1965 Voting Rights Act n't a desire to hide away America past.