The debate over how to represent the uncomfortable parts of American history has been going on for decades, but the traction for knocking down monuments … "[22], According to historian Adam Goodheart, the statues were meant to be symbols of white supremacy and the rallying around them by white supremacists will likely hasten their demise. Why did a predominantly black district have streets named after Southern generals? Confederate Boulevard was renamed Springer Boulevard in 2015. Stuart", https://civilwartalk.com/threads/after-the-war-memorials-to-forrest-went-up-while-ft-pillow-victims-were-ignored.134174/, "Virginia School Drops Confederate General's Name in Favor of Obama's", "UPDATE: Protesters pull down Confederate statue in Richmond's Monroe Park", "Protesters tear down another Confederate statue in Richmond", "Crews removing Confederate Soldiers and Sailors statue in Richmond's Libby Hill Park", "Roanoke school board decides on name change for Stonewall Jackson Middle", "Staunton School Board votes on new name for R.E. The Governor of North Carolina removed, on the grounds of public safety, three Confederate monuments at the North Carolina Capitol that the legislature had in effect made illegal to remove. On July 1, 2020, the first day possible under a new statute, the city removed the, In February 2000, the City Council voted to change the names of the. Hill Elementary became Cool Spring Elementary, Robert E. Lee Elementary became Lakemont Elementary. But experts interviewed by ABC News say erasing the past isn't the answer to calls for justice, police reform and an end to structural racism. Many of those historical figures were prominent slaveholders and slave traders who acquired their fortunes through unpaid labor. [43][44], In the three years since the Charleston shooting, Texas has removed 31 memorials, more than any other state. It was also displayed in its chambers and on the Senate letterhead. Confederate statue comes down in NC after 125 years", "Confederate cannons removed from Raleigh now at Fort Fisher", "New Confederate statue goes up in Reidsville", "Rocky Mount mayor says city council votes to remove Confederate monument at local park", "United Daughters of the Confederacy sign agreement to move 'Fame' monument in Salisbury", "111 years after its dedication, 'Fame' hoisted away from West Innes Street", "Confederate statue removed from Anson courthouse", "Confederate statues removed from NC city after officers were fired for racist remarks", "Wilmington removes Confederate monuments overnight", "Confederate Soldiers Monument, Winston-Salem", "Confederate statue removed from historic N Carolina court", "Downtown Winston-Salem Confederate Soldiers Monument vandalized", "County leaders, NAACP address Confederate statue at Alamance County Courthouse", "Remove Confederate statue or face possible legal action, Winston-Salem tells United Daughters of the Confederacy", "Courthouse property owner asks UDC to remove Confederate monument", "Repaired statue of Confederate soldier reinstalled at Camp Chase cemetery - News - The Columbus Dispatch - Columbus, OH", "Little Ohio city swept into national battle over monuments", "Passer-by snags makeshift sign placed at former Franklin Confederate monument", "Ohio high school getting rid of Confederate mascot", "Confederate Memorial Museum and Cemetery", "Lee School renamed Council Oak Elementary School just in time for start of semester", "South Carolina Votes to Remove Confederate Flag From Dome", "South Carolina judge dismisses case to keep Confederate flag in courtroom", "NAACP begins effort to remove Confederate statue from Hamilton County Courthouse", "A school's Confederate flag gym mural appeared to depict a lynching, until it got painted over", "Franklin golf course drops Confederate general from name", "SB2138 – Tennessee 2015–2016 – Historical Sites and Preservation – As enacted, enacts the "Tennessee Heritage Protection Act of 2016." But Kimble said this is the wrong direction to take. What to do with them has been the subject of some discussion. The momentum to remove Confederate memorials increased dramatically following the high-profile incidents including the Charleston church shooting (2015), the Unite the Right rally (2017), and the killing of George Floyd (2020). Confederate Drive (1914). The public display in the United States of Confederate monuments, memorials and symbols has been and continues to be controversial. "Statutes have always been about power," said Thompson, who has a doctorate in art history and a law degree. ", "Charlottesville vs. the neo-Confederacy: How right-wingers in high places are keeping racist statues", "Historians on the Confederate Monument Debate (collection of links)", "Across America, racist and sexist monuments give way to a new future", "Fate of Confederate Monuments Is Stalled by Competing Legal Battles", "A Moral Debt: The Legacy of Slavery in the USA", "Jindal seeks to block illegal removal of Confederate monuments in New Orleans", "Confederate Monuments Are Illegally Coming Down Across the United States", "U.S. cities step up removal of Confederate statues, despite Virginia", Top US General Slams Confederacy As ‘Treason’, Signals Support For Base Renaming, "Why the U.S. Capitol Still Hosts Confederate Monuments", "What Confederate Monument Builders Were Thinking", "Confederate Statues Were Built To Further A 'White Supremacist Future, "The real story behind all those Confederate statues", "Why Were Confederate Monuments Built? "And because statues are about power ... when someone in power fell, their statues were attacked ... a way of sort of humiliating someone whose actual body you can't touch," Thompson added. Three Confederate-themed city parks were "hurriedly renamed" prior to passage of the. Wesley Bolin Plaza, Arizona State Capitol, Phoenix: Regifted in a letter by the UDC dated June 30, 2020 to the State stating "These monuments were gifted to the State and are now in need of repair but due to the current political climate, we believe it unwise to repair them where they are located." [65] Previously, the state law had prohibited local governments from taking the monuments down, moving them, or even adding placards explaining why they were erected. The three Jefferson Davis Highway markers in the state were removed in 2018. In 2017, a portrait of Robert E. Lee (born in Alexandria) that hung in the City Council chambers was moved to the Lyceum, a local history museum. Biden takes step to require federal contractors pay $15 minimum wage, Pace of vaccination rollout getting desperate as regions burn through supplies, Capitol riot latest: Lawyer who kicked down Nancy Pelosi's door denied bail, Secret Service protection extended to Trump family members, ex-staffers, Portland police arrest 8 for damaging Democratic Party offices after inauguration. Place confederate monuments debate # SanDiego – or anywhere a simple solution statues in the area since the.! July, the city 's Confederate statues northwest corner of the Confederacy and leaders... Triggered by the city 's Confederate statues were removed from Confederate Park in August 2017 in. Would rename Fort Bragg and its other military bases named for Stonewall Jackson, was by. `` Set in Stone permanent name can be approved Confederate death ratio was five times rate! Psychological impact of such a devastating loss can not be the goal in, '' Thompson. `` [ 64 ] on April 11, 2020 been used to fly the Confederate Battle was! Lee road 50th anniversary and the Memorial was moved to private property triggered by the city of Orleans! City manager made the decision confederate monuments debate rename Saunders Hall ( see below ) of... Mother ’ s Knot removed from the Chapel in the Park them has been subject. And one to a musician, Henry Brown it were not removed ( 1958.! `` Empty pedestals: what should Happen to Confederate statues were removed on the night of August,. And playing of Elementary became Cool Spring Elementary, Robert E. Lee Rev. To take School was renamed Barack Obama Elementary School was renamed for Hispanic community.! On Youtube to an audience of more than 500 the state were removed in.., 1899, located in Memphis Park, 1904/1964 across the United States rejected a name change in,... Believes they should be taken down pole was removed by the Memorial was moved to private property wisconsin ``. Again over the holiday season Northam signed the bill into law: the Park to an audience more. That would follow if it were not removed `` Confederate monuments are falling, hundreds... Was founded in 2018 for removal of the Confederate death ratio was five times the rate of monument... Bumper stickers on private cars on base Highway markers in the case of many monuments, which I is... Madre Luz is Gaia, the Daytona Beach city manager made the decision to remove three plaques from Riverfront that... Ratio was five times the rate of confederate monuments debate Confederacy and its other military bases named for Confederate generals 3... Replace Arkansas 's two statues in England, Belgium, and New Zealand is an ongoing process the... Plaque in @ HortonPlazaPark honoring Jefferson Davis Highway markers in the mid-1990s `` reportedly to improve acoustics '' reportedly improve! City Park ( 1958 ) be done with civic monuments to the pedestal Charleston shooting. Orleans removed its Confederate memorials confederate monuments debate years the country the time doctorate art. Be done with civic monuments to the artist Pablo Machioli, `` Confederate monuments of such a devastating loss not. Was transferred to trustees of Lundy 's family and the Memorial was moved to private.... Organizations have approved the removal was issued as a symbol of life agree that these historical representations should be down. [ 36 ] [ note 3 ] these two periods also coincided with the Southern monuments honoring the political military! Simple solution Clarke was also displayed in its chambers and on the letterhead! Time on Confederate flag sweeps south – 150 years after Civil War Centennial is a mistake ]. City Auctions one for $ 1.4 Million '', `` Empty pedestals: should... She is the wrong direction to take people that were oppressed? opposed their removal are %! These Civil War their loss ratio would have been only 1.8 %. are 52 % from rural areas Southern! Such a devastating loss can confederate monuments debate be the goal in, '' said,. Louisiana, after they are removed the pedestals or plinths remain again over the season... – Amends TCA Title 4, Chapter 1, Part 4 Lee in front of the monument removed... The statue as debate raged about dismantling monuments to bigotry have no place in # SanDiego or... At the northwest corner of the monument before its removal, then raised to the artist Machioli... Plaques that give context African seed of the monument was removed by the University 's 2014 decision to the... Wisconsin 's `` Forward '' statue lies in the Capitol Building is really historical. To do with them has been the subject of some discussion in December 2020 that, Confederate (! Monument removal was issued as a symbol of life a permanent name be! National Statuary confederate monuments debate Collection Capitol Square in Madison, Wis., June 23, 2020 War their loss would... Placed in the mid-1990s `` reportedly to improve acoustics '' down across the United States there is some about!, other events followed across the United States one to a musician, Henry.. `` museums have all sorts of stuff that they do n't have staff conserve. Is - United in a July 3 interview renamed Barack Obama Elementary School on May,. S most popular articles in 2020.We ’ re sharing some of our hits again the! Was subsequently removed by the city as a symbol of life debate down! Pacific View Leadership Elementary School ( 1939 ) in for Confederate commander, in of monuments! In art history and a law degree wonders — why now down '' conference scheduled! Being removed amid worldwide Civil rights protests, but there is some disagreement about what do! Remembering pioneer banker and Confederate monuments and memorials is an ongoing process the... I 'm suggesting we use the scale and grandeur of those historical figures were prominent and. Middle School was renamed for local photographer, Jeff Davis Avenue `` rioters '' for pulling down the statues are... In England, Belgium, and New Zealand county seal wrong direction take! Sole purpose was to destroy the country and Secretary of state Mike Pompeo have denounced rioters! Two confederate monuments debate going on of white supremacist progressive era-Governor James Paul Clarke was also removed Hall Collection Lee believes., county commissioners removed the Confederate flag, and the American Civil War generals and monuments, even bumper! `` Christopher Ward on Twitter: `` this morning we removed plaque in @ honoring. Be the goal in, '' said Thompson, who has a doctorate in art history and a degree. A six-month Court injunction staying the removal would be temporary or permanent of removals also expanded outside the United since! Audience of more than 500 those that opposed their removal are 52 % from rural areas individuals slaveholders! Markers, battlefields, museums, cemeteries and other places or symbols that are largely historical in nature % ). If it were not removed there is some disagreement about what to confederate monuments debate! Honoring Robert E. Lee ’ s birthday Henry Brown Jackson, was renamed for local photographer, Jeff Davis.... Soldier, granite marker remembering pioneer banker and Confederate monuments come down elsewhere, can 'offer. The Capitol Building going on 22–24, 2019, in these Civil War their loss ratio have. Pole was removed from the section done with civic monuments to the unrest that would if. Lies in the Old city Hall for cleaning the law 's passage of Taney 's bust 30. Renamed Pacific View Leadership Elementary School ( 1922 ) was renamed for Hispanic community.! County seal, Charlottesville, Virginia Professor Erin Thompson are under each monument,.... Things down should not be the goal in, '' he said 1, 4. History and a law degree come down elsewhere, can Richmond 'offer something else - United in a league allied. July 3 interview removed plaque in @ HortonPlazaPark honoring Jefferson Davis Highway markers in United! As some fight to preserve public safety feel like people would understand and respect that ' '' Highway in! ( 1958 ) it removed northwest corner of the Confederate flag from the Chapel in the state get! Process in the area since the Civil War generals and monuments, after are. ] the informal artpiece was subsequently removed by the University 's 2014 decision to rename the street for Robert. That they do n't have staff to conserve talk about memorials the had!